What is this website about?

My view is that Adam Smith got it right when he noted that pin-making could be made more efficient by dividing the work intelligently.

“The division of labour, so far as it can be introduced, occasions, in every art, a proportional increase in the productive power of labour” (Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations).

But what about the pen? Intellectual labour has been dividing and divided throughout the past five hundred years in a way that fosters isolated (and often irrelevant) specialization. Is there another way of moving forward in the search for relevant understanding, patterns of genuine progress?

That is what this website is about. It is about a revolution in the way those committed to intellectual labour collaborate.

But the revolution is a quiet revolution: it is about a revolving of ideas that would recycle the ideas that contribute to progress. Every area of inquiry is unwittingly struggling towards such a revolving. The website aims at bringing unity and efficiency and light into that struggle. It points towards a collaboration that would link our efforts together so that, instead of each zone and sub-zone of inquiry tunneling along alone, there would be a towering of significant meanings, a twister of truths, a vortex of growing understanding of human possibilities.

In FoeRaum 4, “A Forum for Church and State, School and Bank,” I invite you to think of collaboration as a matter of facing the history of caring and not-caring in all its muddled details. In this essay I parallel the four movements of Beethoven’s 7th symphony with the four paragraphs of Bernard Lonergan talking about “The Problem of History” in the final chapter of Topics in Education. In addition, I ask whether telling the story of the Pygmies, who spent much time in the flow of singing and dancing, has been a victim of  liberalism. In FoeRaum 3, “Forcing Attention,” I parallel the liberal tradition of nation states with the liberal behavior of isolated and inefficient academic disciplines.

For a brief outline of my efforts, beginning in 1966, to understand the way of omni-disciplinary collaboration leading to progress, see Interpretation 21, “Interpreting Lonergan: Trieste I.”

What's new?

Public Challenging Method Board VII Public Challenging Method Board VI Public Challenging Method Board V Public Challenging Method Board IV Public Challenging Method Board III Public Challenging Method Board II Public Challenging Method Board I

"A Paradigmatic Panel Dynamic for (Advanced) Students (of Religion)"
Appendix: Correspondence with Method: Journal of Lonergan Studies

Tinctures of System

Tinctures 6: {M(W3)θΦT}4 Converging the Fifth Column: I Crest My Case

Tinctures 5: Third Objectifications: A Fourth Coming Fifth Column

Tinctures 4: Nudges Towards Thinking Out Tower Topology

Tinctures 3: Identifying Effectively Intentionality Analysis

Tinctures 2: The Obviousness of Intentionality Analysis

Tinctures 1: Tête-à-Tête

Tinctures Zero: Sociology, Situation Rooms, Topologies: Economics and Religion

Rescuing Lonergan: A Series of Vignettes

Vignette 24: "True Peace"

Vignette 23: Among the Lilies

Vignette 22: Mibox

Vignette 21: The Scriptures' Story

Vignette 20: The None's Story

Vignette 19: The Cargo Pants

Vignette 18: Ontic and Phyletic Growth

Vignette 17: Conferences, Gatherings, Papers, Poises

Vignette 16: Academic Disciplines

Vignette 15: A Convenient Naming of Stages of Meaning

An Elementary Forum

Reason and Religious Beliefs

Mount Saint Vincent University videos


1. “This Is Worth a Life”

McShane begins by quoting Stephen McKenna, who, when he discovered Plotinus and pondered the possibility of translating the Greek into English, said “This is worth a life.”  He then introduces the challenge of identifying the basic variables of economics as an empirical science, providing examples from the emergence of the elementary sciences.

play video

With Éamonn de Valera, 1968

Éamonn de Valera was the only leader of the 1916 Easter Revolution in Dublin not executed by the British. The photo of McShane and de Valera was taken in 1968 while de Valera was still President of Ireland.

Nashik, India, 2010

McShane gave the keynote address, and led discussions, for a three-day conference on economic theory in Nashik, India. McShane used examples from his father’s bakery business to introduce the distinct basic and surplus circuits in a dynamic exchange economy.

With Bernard Lonergan, 1971

This photo of Bernard Lonergan and McShane was taken during the summer of 1971 in Dublin. At the time Lonergan was lecturing on Method in Theology at the Milltown Institute.